The Great Wyoming Traffic Jam of 2017

Ok, it took me 2+ days to get back from the eclipse, catch up on my sleep (and food), unpack the car, and start to look at the data. This has been my first chance to get online and upload a few pictures.

I had an extra camera, a simple little "point-and-shoot" snapshot camera, which I wasn't otherwise going to be able to use during the eclipse, so I gave it to one of the kids with a large party from the Merced, CA, area who camped across from me. I wasn't able to collect names, but one of them took this nice shot during totality:
Totality / Nikon
 Coolpix S411 camera
Notice the three (almost four) prominent coronal streamers.

Wikipedia news photoCompare with this thumbnail photo of the inner corona from the front page at Wikipedia 2 days later (over at the "recent news" on the righthand side):

This eclipse was noticeably brighter than the one 38 years ago, meaning the corona was much brighter and more spectacular. I also didn't notice any shadow bands just before (or after) totality this time; they were perhaps the most prominent feature of the previous eclipse, though the sight of the corona at totality is always incredible. Photos really can't convey or give a good impression of what it's like being there. This is probably the result of the corona having a range of brightness of at least 500x, from the faintest outermost whisps to the regions near the sun/moon's limb. The eye is able to accomodate this high dynamic range, which is roughly 9 stops in photographer's lingo, though it's very difficult to compress into the range available with cameras and the means one might use to display the images made with them. Ansel Adams would have said the scene's brilliance is too great for the medium.

 

Our observing site / Nikon
 Coolpix S411 camera
A handful of the kids (with one adult) had wondered over the short distance to a nearby hill with a better
view to the WNW of the approaching shadow about a half hour before totality, providing this excellent
shot looking back in the other direction of the roughly two dozen cars and RV's that had found their way
from around the world to this remote location. There was a couple from Greece I met, as well as one with
a teenage son from Colonge, Germany -- maybe 60-70 people all told, ½ mile south of US Highway 20/26.

The GPS coordinates were measured as: 107° 55' 18.6" (W), +43° 11' 45.3"; 5075 feet. (car @farthest right w/trunk up)
This web app output from NASA shows the relevant stats for this spot:

Observing Site Eclipse Statistic

The nearest point on the centerline SSW of us (i.e., along a perpendicular from it) was 4½ miles away, but this made only a 1.4 second (1%) difference in the length of totality. The point on the centerline which had an exactly identical time of maximum eclipse was a little bit further along the track (more S-SSW from our location) and closer to 4 5/8 or 4 2/3 miles away.

 

Going Nowhere
 at Warp Speed #1
Even after being the last by far to leave the little impromptu observing site 10 miles ESE of
Shosoni, WY, and killing 1½ or two hours in or on the way to Casper, WY, this was what it
looked like an hour before sunset about half of the 110 miles from there SW and S to Rawlings.

 

Going Nowhere
 at Warp Speed #2
Two hours later, and maybe a dozen miles farther south, I snapped this one after pulling off for a
break and to enjoy the last of the sunset. The 6 second time exposure shows a bit of the remaining
twilight sky brightness to the north but gives the impression that the traffic was actually moving.
Only 2 mph is ~3 feet per second, which is ~20 feet over the course of an exposure. I can't say if
the line of light at the far right is cars in the far distance or an internal lens reflection.

 

According to one source, some 600,000 people from Colorado were expected to go up to Wyoming for the eclipse, which only has about that number of people all told (CO has ~5 million) -- and most of them I actually avoided since they were heading back down I-25 from Casper to the large cities of the Front Range. Being around quite a few gas stations and at least one restaurant on the trip, I saw mostly Colorado license plates.

Thanks Wyoming!

Also: thanks to the party from Salt Lake City camping next to me, who had extra reserves of water to share with me, since I only had two quarts. They told me about the almost 2-meter class telescope the astronomy club there was putting the finishing touches on.

ALT-USABy the time I made it to Rawlins and I-80 around 10PM the traffic had thinned sufficiently -- twice as many lanes certainly helped also -- to be back to normal speeds. But in the long stretch of two-lane south to I-70 at Rifle, CO, I started to get blurry-eyed in the early AM hours and had to pull over for a several hour nap, not making it back to Montrose until 8 AM. I quickly turned on the morning TV "news" to catch up on what scientists were reporting about the eclipse, only to be treated to typical celebrity crappage about what Sarah Jessica Parker had seen in New York city, which only had a √2-1 eclipse. Then, as if that wasn't bad enough, they had to have a zany, madcap plot line where one of the show's hosts couldn't find her way out of the studio and down the back stairs to get outside. OMG, she's going to be late for the eclipse! This is criminal misuse of the public airwaves.

Tucker quote

More to follow...

 

An Eclipse Expedition of the Past

 

Bibliography

William H. Calvin (1991), How the Shaman Stole the Moon; Bantam, NY.
Don Lago (2017), Where the Sky Touched the Earth; University of Nevada Press, Reno.
Mark Littmann, Ken Willcox & Fred Espenak (1999), Totality: Eclipses of the Sun, 2nd ed.; Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
Aden & Marjorie Meinel (1983), Sunsets, Twilights, and Evening Skies; Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Tyler Nordgren (2016), Sun Moon Earth: The History of Solar Eclipses; Basic Books, NY.
Donald E. Osterbrock (1988), Eye on the Sky; University of California Press, Berkeley.
Donald E. Osterbrock (1993), Pauper & Prince; University of Arizona Press, Tucson.
Ray A. Williamson (1984), Living the Sky; University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.
Jon Willis (2016), All These Worlds Are Yours; Yale University Press, New Haven.
GPS Coordinate Calculator - the great circle distance app is handy to have for work with any near-spherical surface.
Last year’s solar eclipse set off a wave in the upper atmosphere.
Eclipse Science from 50,000 Feet (abstract): New Coronal Results from NASA WB-57F High-Altitude Aircraft Observations of the 2017 Total Solar Eclipse. [One wishes they'd said whether the photo shown is in "the green line or the nearby continuum".]
Astronomers scrutinized last year’s eclipse. Here’s what they’ve learned.

 


End of 2017 Update

Jules Janssen

A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Eclipse

For anyone who's been checking, I haven't posted anything new here since shortly after the eclipse -- as a result of being given a case of HOA Syndrome: three weeks before the eclipse, the Montrose Mafia stole my car out of my driveway, forcing me at first to think I was going to have to ride my bicycle ~400 miles to the centerline, and then later to get my collector car out of mothballs at the last minute in order to make it to the eclipse [HOA = Home Owners Association].

I get around entirely by bicycle, for 4 years now, so them putting my now stolen and held hostage car 10 miles away made it impossible to try and retrieve. For one thing it needed a new battery, which weighs some 25-30 pounds. For another, I'd been siphoning all the old gas out of it over the Summer (and burning it in the BBQ), in preparation for taking it to the eclipse, and there are no gas stations within about 8 miles of where they had it, so I also would have had to bicycle down there with at least 1-2 gallons of gasoline. For a third, it hadn't been run for 4 years, and while I would have expected it to start up fairly easily, in the event that it didn't there was no auto service nearby, just like there wasn't any gas.

Cults & HOAs

Not only were they expecting me to also give them nearly a kilobuck for the 'privilege' of being harassed, bullied, and robbed by the property management company's Mr. Big and his lawyers, NOW they've upped the ante and are suing me for $4.3K -- on a car that was likely worth less than a half that! It's sixteen years old, has been hit by a deer, and needed some other fixes, like for the cracked windshield it's had for 7 years.

Anyone up for starting a legal defense fund? Running legal plunder total so far: $92 (to file an ~85 word statement w/the court, for the equivalent of ~3 weeks worth of groceries- gah!)
Anyone know any lawyers? Anybody have a Varon-T disruptor I can borrow? My Higgs field enhanced model (v.2) is still under construction.

Or maybe one of you 'special-ops' types can get the GPS coordinates 38°28½'N, 107°52½W on North Korea's ICBM targeting list. That'd fix `em real good.

HOA Syndrome is a form of anxiety disorder, and the list of ~25 indicators for it, well, I've got at least a half dozen of them -- plus a few that aren't listed, like my cat's behavior; pets act as a mirror on their owner's mental state.

On top of that, MicroSoft dumped an "update" on me two or three weeks after the eclipse, and now my programming environment no longer works. I was right in the middle of writing some code to do some calculations and make a graph, but attempts to figure out what went wrong and how to fix it have been to no avail... Well, it must have been some obscure compiler glitch, because switching a few lines of code around, which shouldn't have made any difference at all, made the bug go away. So here's the graph:

Synthetic limb darkened sun. Graph of light fall-off before a total solar eclipse.
Landscape illumination fall-off for a representative total solar eclipse.
The sun is taken to be 30 arc-minutes in diameter, the moon 31 arc-minutes. The latter moves across the former at the constant rate of 1 arc-minute every 2½ minutes, which is thus the length of totality. It then takes 75 minutes from 1st to 2nd contact. These are all roughly typical if somewhat idealized values. The observer is assumed to be right on the centerline.
[The sun's mean angular diameter is almost exactly 32 arc-minutes, and ranges ~±½ arc-minute, from 32.532 at perihelion to 31.462 at aphelion. Thus, total eclipses are more likely May-August than November-February.
At the moon's mean distance, its angular size is 31.56 arc-minutes at the sub-lunar point on earth -- when the moon is at the observer's zenith (its closest distance) -- and 31.04 arc-minutes when the moon is E or W on the observer's horizon (farthest away but still visible). The numbers range from 29.91 to 33.45 arc-minutes for the first case, 29.44 to 32.86 for the less favorable configuration.
The mean angular rates of motion for the moon and sun, in either arc-seconds per second or arc-minutes per minute, are 0.5444 and 0.04107. For the case of a moving moon over-taking a moving sun, since they're both moving in the same direction (E), these combine so it takes just short of 2 time minutes for the moon to move 1 arc-minute relative to the sun (119 seconds). Since eclipses are more likely to occur when the moon is at perigee, and thus larger in angular size, but also moving more rapidly than the mean, and because eclipses are also more likely to occur at aphelion, when the sun is smaller in angular size, but also moving more slowly than the mean, the more typical rate of over-take might be closer to 110 (or 100) seconds per arc-minute. So a rate of 2½ minutes (150 seconds) is a very slow eclipse, by about a third. This is why it takes 75 minutes here, rather than a more typical 55-65 minutes in the real world.]
The blue curve shows the illumination level fall-off for a synthetic, computer generated, limb darkened sun (at left/left), using the simple empirical relationship in Hestroffer & Magnan (1997) -- their Eq. 1, with the parameter values for u and α from the caption to Fig. 2. As their reference wavelength is λ = 579.88 nm, this model may underestimate the actual visual (λ = 555 nm) limb darkening very slightly, because of its wavelength dependence, being less at longer ones. For those using other limb darkening models, the sun I generate is 75.7% the brightness of a uniform disk -- the green curve, which crosses above the blue one at T = 41:35 (m:s). Each curve is normalized to its own unobstructed (total) level so this difference doesn't show in the graph.
The solid part of each curve starts after the level is down to 10% of full sun, at T = 8:50 for the blue curve (green: 6:20).
As the total brightness of the
corona may be several hundredths of a percent that of the full sun, below Log I ≈ -3 or -3½ its contribution, which varies from eclipse to eclipse and is not factored in here, will start to become significant. This happens in the final ~20 seconds before 2nd contact.
Eclipse landscape photographers may be interested in the graph in table form.


Continuing... And then, barely a week after getting back from the eclipse, there was the 8th-9th magnitude Asteroid 3122 Florence flying by close to the earth; it won't be back for several hundred years. I got 5 hours of great observations (some 700+ frames), and have been assembling a time-lapse movie when I get a chance.

Regulus & 2017
 Solar Eclipse

But I did get some excellent results for the eclipse, like a picture during totality showing Regulus in the frame (a section of which is shown at right), which I haven't seen anywhere else. My focal length was chosen with doing this very thing in mind. I also haven't heard of anyone noticing it visually during the eclipse. Everyone I talked with beforehand was looking to see planets during totality. [Actually, I finally saw such a shot, in late April, 2018. It went by on the local TV news very quickly, so I don't know it's source. There was no credit pasted onto the photo. It was shown as part of a voice-overed promo for an upcoming segment and was not shown again during the piece itself.]

This view is in an Alt-Az orientation; Regulus was actually ~½ arc-minute N of the Sun in equatorial/celestial coordinates then (39 arc-seconds). The ecliptic goes below Regulus. It was 1.3° from the center of the Sun, or almost 5 (4.96) solar radii (Rο). The outermost coronal streamers seen here hit the frame edge at a little less than 4½ (4.45) Rο. At shorter exposure levels all the streamers go straight in to 1 Rο, so they're almost more in the way of jets emanating from the surface (photosphere or chromosphere).

When I got around (almost a year later) to integrating the Alt/Az field rotation rate equation, from the time of observation to the meridian, I got a total field rotation amount of 28½° (28.46). So celestial N is almost in the 11 o'clock direction (which would be 30°).

[It took 575 lines of computer code -- though I use a lot of comments. As is typical for such a project, the integration (numerical summation) itself only takes ~20 lines, while the rest gets everything set up to perform it.

Besides the observer's geographical coordinates and the object's celestial coordinates, the date and time of observation are also needed. The date is used to determine the Julian Day Number, which is used with the local clock time (Time Zone time) and the observer's longitude to perform the transformation into Local Sidereal Time. This gives the all important Hour Angle. Then with all these in hand one can calculate the Altitude, Azimuth, and Field Rotation Rate. With an Hour Angle of ~1½ hrs I decided to break the integration down to ~5500 one second steps.

Uncle George

The speed of modern computers is completely astounding: when Duffett-Smith wrote Astronomy With Your Personal Computer (1985), calculating a sine or cosine was so computationally expensive (slow) that he used the old trick of only calculating any trigonometric function once and then storing the result in a variable, which is much quicker to access or retrieve when needed. Each step in the field rotation rate integration involves the calculation of about 15 trig functions in getting the Altitude, Azimuth, and Field Rotation Rate, or almost 100,000 in all with my step size. But it happens instaneously to all appearances when I hit <CR>. In fact, expecting there to be a pause (and maybe a long one), when I first ran the code I thought it must somehow be skipping the integration loop because it came back so fast -- except that it was giving the same result (28 5/8°) as I'd gotten from measuring the angles between the few other stars visible besides Regulus (see next).

BTW - There's a minor bug in a popular document which might trip people up a little who try doing this at home... if you do a search on keywords like "Altitude Azimuth Mount Field Rotation" you may easily turn up a PDF file by Bill Keicher, dated 12 March 2005. The title of this research paper is Field Rotation in Altitude over Azimuth Mounts and Its Effects on CCD Imaging -- What is the Maximum Exposure?. My copy of the paper has the filename Field Rotation V3.pdf. The problem is in Appendix A (Mathematics of Field Rotation in an Alt/Az Mount), pg 13. There we find the equation for the field rotation rate, and the constant W:
W = 4.178E-03 Earth rotation in degrees/sidereal second (emphasis mine)
The problem is that this is the rate in degrees per solar second, not per sidereal second. In sidereal seconds the coefficient is 4.16666... (1/240) rather than 4.178. (The exponent stays the same.) Any field will rotate once all the way around (360°) in a sidereal day; since a sidereal day is shorter than a solar day, a solar second is longer than a sidereal second, and the rate constant is higher when using solar seconds. Work it out for and convince yourself that you want to use the slightly smaller value when integrating over a change in Hour Angle, since this is based on Local Sidereal Time.]

There are two 7th magnitude stars in the field near Regulus. In this orientation, one (HD 87647 / SAO 98949, 7.35 mag) is ~1° almost directly above Regulus, while the other (HD 87271 / SAO 98931, 7.10 mag) is almost the same amount directly to its right. The latter star is lost in the bright coronal streamer near the right edge of this crop, but the other is easily visible (if on the faint side) in the original frame above what's shown here.

[An approximation exists for the conversion between Naked Eye Limiting Magnitude (NELM) and sky brightness in Magnitudes Per Square Arc-Second (MPSAS), courtesy of K. Fisher. Unfortunately his chart only goes as bright as MPSAS=16, where the NELM=2.2, which is about a magnitude fainter than Regulus (1½). While I had aspirations of measuring the sky brightness directly during totality (with a meter), I wasn't able to do so (not enough hands), though post-eclipse estimations and test/calibration exposures during twilight ~25 minutes before sunrise put it closer to 13½-14. Extrapolating Fisher's relationship to this level puts NELM at -0.2 to +0.3, which is too bright by at least a magnitude to have allowed Regulus to have been seen, especially so close to the bright corona, perhaps explaining the observations (or lack thereof). Mars, at mag 1.9, 8¼° above and to the right of the eclipse, also should have been beyond apprehension, but more distant Venus (34°), at -3¾ below Gemini should have been easily visible. After doing the above I found this nifty and handy NELM / MPSAS Conversion Calculator, which gives the same results.]

Will Rogers quote

I also got a great sequence of the Diamond Ring effect, and, more importantly, a good timing of its duration accurate to ±½ second or better, something else I haven't seen anywhere else before. This in turn gives a measure of the physical depth of the canyon on the limb of the moon responsible for it. Before releasing the figure I wanted to make a survey of peoples' subjective determination of the effect's length, to compare "eclipse time" with the hard and fast measure from an unaffected clock.

Nuke Stupidville, Not Hawaii!

car picture

Still confused about the car? Yes, you should be. What happened was I parked it as I always did in my driveway. Then I took to my bicycle. No problemo. There the car sat for 1, 2, 3, 4, .... 46, 47, 48, 49 months. I cleared the snow off it when needed, pumped up the tires when they started to look a little low, etc. (The relevant legal concept here is called "Acquiescence" or "course of conduct".)

Evidently 50 months was one too many, as Mr. Big then declared my car "abandoned" -- by having a hoakey "notice" (printed on bright red paper, to look important or official, or something) taped onto the windshield. The basis for this was that the registration tags on the car were expired (not one, two, or three years, but four), something which could only have been determined by someone trespassing onto my side of the invisible three-foot property line around my house, as I always back a car in when parking, so the license plate was up against the garage door.

There was supposedly a way to contest the notice to the Property Theft Mgmt company, which I did by explaining I was in fact going to get the car registered within about another two months in order to drive it to the eclipse (which was also why I held on to the car rather than sell it). What possible difference could 51 months vs. 49 months and a 1 square inch little sticker make to anyone with half a brain left? Not much, so obviously this made little impression. Then the threatening and harassing letters from the lawyers started, followed by them sending their thugs to tow the car away. One threatened to "call the sheriff" when I protested, which I probably should have encouraged him more to do, while the other one was just muscle who didn't say anything. Strongarm didn't bother to show up himself.

Hard of Hearing - Don't
 Shoot!

As Mr. Big had been over here practically ranting at me about how he was going to foreclose on (read: steal) my home -- which made no sense since I have no mortgage (the place is fully paid for) -- this ought to eventually make an interesting test case for Colorado's "Make My Day!" law. The last scum lawyer that screwed me over got investigated by the FBI and did several (4?) years in Leavenworth, so someone ought to warn them off.

Homeowners Concentration
 Camps

A copy of a letter I sent to my HOA neighbors has another choice Ward Lucas quote in it. He's the only person ever to have cooked up a batch of chili with a solar oven during the two hour stretch of a total eclipse from first to fourth contact!

The previous HOA president replied to my letter, starting out, in typical cult-like, Nazi-esque fashion, by lecturing me on "how we must all follow the rules, like it or not". Like H.L. Mencken said, in his typically acerbic and facetious manner, "the goosestep is the perfect symbol of 'civilization'."

What's actually funny about all this is that as a homeowner I'm ostensibly part of the homeowner's association, which means I'm suing myself, without having done anything! Either way I win. It's kind of like some sort of Jedi trick, only backwards.

Edgar Rice Burroughs quote

 

The Tyson Effect?

 

Tip Me Please!

©2017, Chris Wetherill. All rights reserved. Display of words or photos here does NOT constitute or imply permission to store, copy, republish, or redistribute my work in any manner for any purpose without expressed prior permission.

 

Beam Me UP, Scotty!

-------------------------------

[ Back to Main VISNS Page ]